FANDOM



Theory: Who is the Forgotten Warrior?

Theory Creator: Leopardclaw
Why I think this: OOTS, POT

Agreeing Users:
Sign below if you agree with this theory

It seems obvious, yet if you think about it, It could be lots of cats.

Disagreeing Users:
Sign below if you agree with this theory
Leopardclaw

Paleclaw

Right, so I know you all think it's Hollyleaf, and the Erins are making it far too obvious and Blah Blah Blah.

So I was thinking. What if Hollyleaf really is dead?

See my theory on why I think this here.

So if Hollyleaf is dead, I made a list of othe cats the Forgotten warrior might be. Including Hollyleaf. (Non Biasedly...)

HollyleafEdit

Reasons ForEdit

She apparently lives. Jayfeather found a scrap of her fur in a tunnel, so we assume she lives. And "Hollyleaf" guided some cats out of the tunnel. Apparently.

Reasons againstEdit

She is dead. (My theory again). What if she is dead? And I can still remember her.

Cinderpelt/heartEdit

This isn't actually one I thought of, but I thought of some reasons.

Reasons ForEdit

This is an interesting one. Cinderpelt isn't forgotten as such, but Cinderheart has a part of Cinderpelt and this is forgotten. I probably don't make sense, but I'm trying to say that Cinderheart has "forgotten" that she is Cinderpelt.

Reasons AgainstEdit

It could just be a stab in the dark.

Fallen LeavesEdit

Reasons ForEdit

He is forgotten by everyone. Literally. All his family and Tribemates left him behind in the tunnels. They forgot about him. He is unknown to most of the cats of the current Clans. All but Jayfeather.

Reasons AgainstEdit

He is dead, and he is a ghost, so he can't do much physically.

Half MoonEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Does anyone remember her as the first Stoneteller? Was she even mentioned before SOTM? The tribe certainly don't remember her, and she is definetly not mentioned unless in a story of the tribe, but not in person.

Reasons AgainstEdit

She's dead too. And she's not a ghost. And she's not in StarClan.

RockEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Rock sits in his tunnels, having watched and been forgotten since forever. He was forgotten by all cats in the time of the ancients, and in the current time, Jayfeather doesn't seem to be speaking to him at the minute. Plus, he has connections with StarClan.

Reasons AgainstEdit

He is really old. REALLY old. And he may be dead. And he may be a ghost.

FirestarEdit

Reasons ForEdit

He isn't forgotten as such. But in the books, his deeds have been forgotten. He's now, to many people, just an old ginger tom who needs to die.

Reasons AgainstEdit

He isn't forgotten.

ThistleclawEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Coming soon

Reasons AgainstEdit

Coming soon

MapleshadeEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Coming soon

Reasons AgainstEdit

Coming soon

TigerstarEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Coming soon

Reasons AgainstEdit

Coming soon

IvypoolEdit

Reasons ForEdit

Coming soon

Reasons AgainstEdit

Coming soon

My ConclusionEdit

I think the most likely cats on my list to be the Forgotten Warrior are Cinderpelt/heart or Fallen Leaves. Or possibly both. It could be Cinder physically and Fallen Leaves spiritually.

Ad blocker interference detected!


Wikia is a free-to-use site that makes money from advertising. We have a modified experience for viewers using ad blockers

Wikia is not accessible if you’ve made further modifications. Remove the custom ad blocker rule(s) and the page will load as expected.